Introduction
Cotey Chemical Corporation was
founded in Lubbock, Texas, in 1949 by Mr. Bradford J. Cotey.
Our mission is to provide products which can be safely and
easily applied by non-technical personnel for maintenance,
development or sterilization of household, industrial and irrigation
water wells.
Cotey Chemical has, during almost
half a century, developed a well-earned reputation for leadership
in the marketing of superior products for the water well industry.
Satisfied clients, located throughout the United States and
many foreign countries, substantiate the attainment of Mr.
Cotey's motto - "BETTER WELLS WITH COTEY CHEMICALS".
This manual is provided for
guidance in the use of Cotey Chemical Products. Data is based
on the latest information available, but the particular suitability
for specific applications should be substantiated by each user's
own tests.
Data provided in this manual
must be considered as being provided and accepted at each individual's
risk. Cotey Chemical Corporation guarantees no specific results
and cannot assume obligation or liability in connection with
supplied products.
Chemical Treatment
of Water Wells
Any water well can be treated
with any number of chemicals at any time, but such treatments
do not necessarily benefit the well or increase productive
capacity. For example, water wells developed in crystalline
rock (granite, diorite, monzonite, etc.) can seldom be improved
by acid treatments, and no chemical can increase the production
of wells which have simply pumped all of the available water.
It is therefore important, when considering a chemical stimulation
program, to correctly identify the reason(s) for the decreased
well yield. COTEY CHEMICAL personnel will gladly help you with
such problems.
Decreased water well yields
may result from many independent, or several contributory factors.
The proper steel may not have been used during well construction
and considerable corrosion of the well screen or casing may
have occurred. Pumping velocities may have been excessive,
or a poor gravel-pack construction may be allowing passage
of excessive amounts of silt and clay. Unfortunately, the reasons
for such problems cannot be corrected with chemicals, although
the results may be correctable on a short-term basis. Commonly,
the initial yield of a well may decrease because of movement
of the well screen or casing, or because of incrustations of
calcium carbonates and iron and manganese hydroxides/hydrated
oxides and bacterial slimes, or because of simple silt and
clay plugging. Recent developments and uses of various exotic
metal alloys and plastics for well casings and screens, many
contractors believe, prevent incrustation problems, but studies
document that plastic screens and even fiberglass pipes do
experience incrustation problems in many areas. The problems
can be successfully alleviated by chemical treatments - particularly
by using products developed by COTEY CHEMICAL. Thus, let's
examine each of the principal clogging mechanisms, the recommended
treatment programs needed for correction, and the specific
COTEY products.
First though, a word about the
time necessary for good chemical treatment of a water well.
The speed of almost any chemical reaction is more or less proportional
to the temperature, thus, the warmer the well water the faster
will be the reaction time to COTEY'S chemicals and the shorter
the down time. Unfortunately, in most cases well water will
be cool (<60 degrees F), thus the time needed for adequate
chemical treatment may seem unusually long and, in many cases,
is often cut short by impatient landowners, drillers, or service
companies. This is, of course, tantamount to using the wrong
chemical or less than required amounts of the right chemical,
either one of which is bad business for all concerned. COTEY
therefore recommends that if the well cannot be shut down for
the needed time period, the chemical treatment should be postponed
until the required "down time" can be scheduled.
This manual attempts to outline
the various specific uses and applications of COTEY CHEMICAL'S
products, and a summation of each product is given in the Product
Sheets section. The use of complex chemical equations, technical
terminology, and involved reactions is kept to a minimum although
a certain familiarity is required for a competent knowledge
on the part of representatives, service companies, and local
advisory personnel. COTEY CHEMICAL realizes that wells often
exhibit what might be termed "individual chemical idiosyncrasies",
thus COTEY encourages product users to contact the company
for technical assistance. COTEY can also supply professional
supervisory personnel for development of a large deep well
or the treatment of a large well field.
What Makes a Good
Water Well
There are three main ingredients
that go into making a good water well: the drilling, the pumping
and the development. The first two are indispensable since
an opening of some kind has to be made into the water bearing
formation and some means has to be supplied for lifting the
water to the surface even if it's only a bucket tied to the
end of a rope.
Under drilling we can include
all the various methods used: direct and reverse circulation
rotary, cable tool, scow, driven points and even hand dug wells.
Also, we can include running the casing, setting the screen,
strainer or liner, cementing, undereaming, gravel packing and
all other work done in connection with the construction of
the hole.
Under pumping we can include
all means of artificial lift, such as deep well turbine, jet,
rod, submersible, centrifugal and other pumps. We can also
include air-lift and natural artisan flows.
The third ingredient, the development
of the well is too often neglected. Many wells are drilled
and a pump installed and whatever flow is obtained is accepted
even though it may not be as much water as is needed or desired.
Many times it is assumed that this is all the water the formation
will give up. That probably is not true and the flow could
be increased with proper development.
There are many mechanical methods
used for developing water wells such as: simply bailing the
hole, pumping, back washing or back lashing with the pump,
surging with the surge block, explosives, jetting, surging
with compressed air, fracturing and other methods used in an
effort to open up the perforations and formation by force.
You will note that in all of
these mechanical methods the force or pressure being applied
is from the well bore out into the formation which is the same
direction as the force was applied that put any plugging in
place during the drilling operation.
The method being accepted more
and more as the most effective way to open up the perforations
and the water bearing formation to increase the flow is the
use of properly designed chemical treatments.
A great many chemicals have
been dumped in wells in an effort to clean up the hole. Various
acids have been used, soaps, detergents similar to household
cleaners, water softening chemicals, chelating agents, wetting
agents, carbide and believe it or not - even Alka-Seltzer has
been used.
There are several
requirements that any chemical should meet if it is to be used
for treating water wells. First, of course, it should be effective
in dissolving, disintegrating and dispersing commercial drilling
muds, clays and shales so that they can be easily bailed or
pumped out. It should be capable of dissolving limestone and
water deposited scales, corrosion products and organic growths.
It should be relatively non-toxic and should not contaminate
the water. It should be safe to use on the mechanical equipment
in the well. It should also be safe and easy to handle. From
your standpoint, as the contractor or well service company,
it should be a service you can perform without any additional
equipment. For big jobs there are service companies available
in some areas to chemically treat water wells. However, in
most cases the cost is too high to justify their use. Consequently
many wells are not treated that really should be.
Looking at it again from the
contractor's or well service company's point of view, it is
now possible, with the chemicals that have been developed specifically
for treating water wells, to include chemical treating along
with your other services thus adding additional profit to the
job and at the same time making a better well for your customer.
Before any chemical treatment
is considered it is necessary to admit or establish the fact
that some water has been plugged off and that a chemical treatment
is the easiest and most effective method of removing any plugging.
Some drillers are reluctant to admit the possibility that some
water may be plugged off during the drilling operation. They
feel it may be a reflection on their ability and some claim
that if the water is there they will get it. This is not always
true as borne out by the fact that many old wells made more
water after treatment that they did when first completed, showing
that some water had been plugged off all the time.
When you consider the pressures
and methods used in drilling you can see that for all practical
purposes it is almost impossible to drill a well without plugging
off at least some water.
With this chart we have tried
to represent some of the things that happen when a well is
drilled with the rotary method. These things will occur whether
the drilling is by direct or reverse circulation. In order
to drill a fluid must be circulated to remove the cuttings
and hold up the hole. In most all cases mud is used. It can
be commercial drilling mud or as happens in most wells, there's
enough clay in the formation to make a heavy mud as drilling
progresses. As the formation is penetrated a mud or filter
cake is built up on the walls of the hole. The mud cake must
be strong enough to hold the pressure of the column of mud
in the hole; otherwise, you will lose circulation and all the
mud will go back in the formation. If the mud is too thin the
mud cake will build up too far back in the formation and will
be more difficult to remove. If the mud is too heavy the mud
cake may get too thick and stick the bit.
After the well is drilled it
is necessary to remove all the mud cake if the well is to be
developed to its maximum capacity. Using this illustration
you will note that at the static water level of 200 feet the
mud was put in place under 125 PSI pressure and at 300 feet
it was 188 PSI. Now, after all the mud has been removed from
the hole by bailing or pumping, the only pressure available
to push the mud off the wall and out of the formation is the
pressure of the water in the formation. At the static water
level of 200 feet there is no pressure. At 300 feet the maximum
pressure would be only about 43 PSI and this could only be
if the formation had uniform vertical permeability which is
rarely if ever found. There usually will be several clay or
shale breaks which will reduce the total pressure.
So we have the following condition
- mud put in place under 125 PSI at the static water level
and no water pressure to remove it, and at 300 feet mud put
in the formation at 188 PSI and at most, only 43 PSI water
pressure to push it out. Naturally, the deeper the hole and
the less standing water there is, the greater the differential
pressure.
With
cable tool or spudder drilling, the same thing occurs but the
pressure is applied in a different manner. This drawing represents
roughly what happens. As the heavy tool is raised and dropped
a tremendous force is developed on the face of the bit. This
force acts in a direction at right angles to the face of the
bit. As a result as drilling progresses, the formation around
the well bore is compacted and the mud and slush in the hole
is pounded back into the formation. Here again, the only pressure
available to remove any plugging is the water pressure in the
formation which will never anywhere near equal the pressure
built up by the heavy tool string. Scow drilling, driving casing
and reaming also have similar action which tends to plug off
some water. The effect of this plugging is naturally a lower
specific capacity.
In a sand and gravel well you
wind up with a mud cake on the walls and the formation compacted
around the well bore. Since this is behind the casing or screen
and behind the gravel pack, purely mechanical means will not
be effective in removing it. In order to get maximum capacity
all the mud must be removed and the formation opened up to
allow free flow of water from the formation into the well bore.
Silts and Clay Buildups
Older water wells frequently
experience yield declines due to the buildup of silt and clay
in the aquifer near the well or in the well's gravel pack,
whereas newly drilled wells may not yield expected amounts
of water due to "mud-cake" partially sealing the
aquifer. In many cases this "mud-cake", consisting
of fine silts and clay particles, is partially cemented or
consists of minute calcium carbonate fragments, however, standard
treatment by many acids will aggravate rather than correct
the problem. This results from the acids dissolving cations
present in the clay, thereby allowing precipitation of free
silicon dioxide (SiO2) as a gel. COTEY CHEMICAL therefore developed
Dry Acid® which, not only dissolves the "mud-cake",
but acts as a strong sequestering agent which prevents precipitation
or flocculation of the silt and clay particles.
Dry Acid is also recommended
for new wells, particularly if developed in carbonate aquifers.
The Dry Acid will effectively prevent buildup of "mud-cake" if
used during the drilling of the well or will quickly remove
the "mud-cake" after the well has been drilled. Secondly,
Dry Acid is to be recommended over the often used canister
of single phosphates thrown down the well to "clean out
the muds" because single polyphosphates act as a food
source for algae, having no ingredient to kill bacteria and
sterilize the well. Dry Acid , other than simply attacking
carbonate content in the well, will also completely sterilize
the well, certainly a tertiary benefit of major importance
at minimal cost.
For wells developed in areas
where carbonate is not a problem, "mud-cake", silts
and clays, and even oil from oil-lubricated turbine pumps,
can be removed by COTEY CHEMICALS Mud-Nox. Essentially, Mud-Nox
(a 100 percent active biodegradable octyl phenoxy polyethoxy
ethanol) is a superior wetting agent and emulsifier which disperses
silts and clays, allowing the particles to be pumped to waste
instead of collecting in the well. The emulsification properties
insure that any oil in the well will also be mixed with water,
and thus also ejectable to waste. Mud-Nox is compatible with
all common solvents except the high aliphatics such as kerosene
and gasoline.
Carbonate Scales
Probably more water wells experience
decreased yields due to incrustations of calcium carbonate
(CaCO3) or calcium magnesium carbonate (CaMg(CO3)2) than from
any other type of incrustation. Carbonate scales form mainly
in water wells producing from hard water aquifers, thus wells
located in the hard water areas of the United States may experience
such problems.
Carbonate scales are vigorously
attacked by acids, the two most commonly used in the water
well treatment industry being muriatic or hydrochloric acid
(HC1) and sulfamic acid (NH2SO3H). Sulfamic acid is the basis
for COTEY CHEMICALS Dry Acid® Special.
Many contractors have used liquid
hydrochloric acid (muriatic) in wells plugged by carbonate
scales, usually because of local availability and cost. COTEY
CHEMICAL, however, strongly discourages use of liquid muriatic
acid because of the absence of inhibitors, the possibility
of "blowouts", and the prudent safety precautions
which should be followed which call for special injection and
handling equipment.
The presence of an inhibitor
in any water well acid is necessary to prevent destruction
of the well screen and pitting of the casing, thus COTEY CHEMICAL
uses a very effective inhibitor in its Dry Acid® Special.
Table 1 illustrates the relative corrosion rates of various
metals commonly used in water well construction when treated
with (inhibited) COTEY CHEMICALS Dry Acid® Special, commercial
muriatic acid, and commercial sulfuric acid. As illustrated,
commercial muriatic acid will not only dissolve carbonate scale
but, for instance, with 1010 steel pipe, will dissolve the
steel pipe over four times as fast as would COTEYS Dry Acid® Special
, unless an inhibitor is added (at extra cost): COTEYs Dry
Acid® Special , with its inhibited action, is, however,
safe for well screens and pumps.
Table 1 - Relative corrostion rates
of various metals commonly used in water wells from
Dry Acid® Special , muriatic acid and sulfuric acid.
|
|
Metals
|
Dry Acid Special |
Muriatic Acid |
Sulfuric Acid |
| 1010
steel |
1.0 |
4.2 |
2.6 |
| Cast
iron |
1.0 |
3.2 |
3.2 |
| Galvanized |
1.0 |
rapid |
63.0 |
| Tin
Plate |
1.0 |
23.0 |
81.0 |
| 304
Stainless |
1.0 |
resistant |
10.0 |
| Copper |
1.0 |
6.7 |
1.5 |
| Brass |
1.0 |
2.8 |
1.5 |
| Bronze |
1.0 |
7.0 |
4.0 |
| Aluminum |
1.0 |
5.3 |
0.6 |
The result of injecting hundreds
of gallons of muriatic acid into a water well drilled through
or into limestones and/or dolomites is often a "blowout"-the
blowback to surface of the acid and water mixture due to the
rapid production of tremendous quantities of CO2 gas. Such
a "blowback" is dangerous to the people working around
the well, contaminates the surrounding field, and is very difficult
to clean up. Dry Acid® Special, is an inert powder which
is non-toxic, non-explosive and non-fuming, can be safely and
slowly added to a water well without special training or special
holding tanks and hoses. The slow rate of injection and dissolution
eliminates the possibility of a "blowout" and, as
a powder, there is no emergency if a spill does occur.
The reaction of almost any acid
added to a water well releases free hydrogen, thus if iron
sulfide is present in the well the "rotten egg" gas,
hydrogen sulfide (H2S), will be formed. Hydrogen sulfide, as
well as carbon dioxide(CO2), which may be blowing back, are
both heavier than the air, thus the well pit or house, or any
adjacent low area, will fill with the heavier gas and the oxygen
will be displaced. It is therefore prudent to stay out of well
pits during treatment and to conduct chemical treatments only
with assistance.
In wells producing from limestone
the problem is somewhat different. Limestone is calcium carbonate
which is completely soluble in acid. By dissolving part of
the formation the channels leading into the well bore are enlarged,
thus allowing more water to enter and the flow to increase.
Some wells are producing from fissures and cracks in formations
that are not soluble in any chemical and wells such as these
cannot be helped with any chemical treatment. In these, shooting
might be a possibility.
It isn't necessary to get deep
penetration into the formation in order to get big increases
in yield. The total surface area increases rapidly so that
back in the formation there is a big drainage area and the
restriction is right at the wall of the hole. This is similar
to having a system with a great many one inch pipes all connected
to a one inch common header. The capacity of the system is
limited to the capacity of the header regardless of how many
one inch pipes are connected to it. To increase the capacity
of the system all you have to do is increase the size of the
header. Essentially this is what is done when the area around
the bore hole is opened up.
In old wells the decrease in
flow may be due to a build up of water deposited scale on the
screen, casing or in the formation. Since most of the pressure
and temperature change which is responsible for the deposition
of the scale occurs at or near the face of the formation, most
of the plugging will be concentrated there. Usually these deposits
are acid soluble and can be readily removed with an acid treatment.
However, in some cases these deposits may be a silica material
and usually it will not be economical or practical to attempt
to remove this by chemical treatment.
Some waters are very corrosive
and the metal in the well will be corroded and the corrosion
products which always occupy more space than the original metal
will accumulate and plug the well. These are sometimes difficult
to remove but usually a chemical treatment will give the desired
results.
Iron and Manganese
Scales
Ground water commonly contains
iron (Fe) in solution as ferric (Fe+++) or ferrous (Fe++) salts,
the ferric iron in solution in amounts greater than 0.01 pm
only at a pH less than 5.0. The ferrous ions allow the growth
of iron fixing bacteria such as Siderocapsa, Gallionella or
Spirophyllum, Crenothrix and Leptothrix which oxidize dissolved
iron and manganese, causing precipitation of iron scale and/or
iron "slime" and manganese hydroxide. The sulfate-reducing
bacteria Dusulfovibrio desulfuricans also produce an iron "slime".
Manganese hydroxide or manganese carbonate is apparently produced
by bacteria extracting manganese from plant life. Within the
well, deposits of ferric oxide scale will be brownish to reddish
brown whereas the hydrated ferrous oxide and the manganese
oxide will be a black to very dark brown.
When well water containing ferrous
(Fe++) iron is pumped to surface the oxygen causes precipitation
of ferric hydroxide (Fe(OH)3) by oxidation, thus lowering the
pH of the well water by removing the bicarbonate (HCO3-) ion.
Manganese, as iron, also occurs
in well water, but in two oxidized states: Mn++ and Mn++++.
The typical reaction which occurs when well water containing
manganese is pumped to surface is simple oxidation to form
manganese hydroxide. Manganese in ground water results from
leaching of soils, industrial wastes and bacterial contributions,
amounts exceeding 0.30 ppm being deleterious for human water
supplies. Most ground water contains less than 0.20 ppm Mn,
but in mining areas or areas experiencing leaching by water
which has been reduced, Mn may exceed 1.0 ppm.
Iron scale, iron bacteria, sulfate-reducing
bacteria, manganese hydroxide and manganese carbonate scales
are all soluble in acids, thus COTEY CHEMICALS Dry Acid® Special
AND Liquid Acid Descaler are the recommended products. The
use of Dry Acid® Special was previously described, thus
let's look at COTEY'S Liquid Acid Descaler.
Liquid Acid Descaler is a potent
combination of acids with a nonionic surfactant which promotes
emulsions. Laboratory and field research by DuPont Chemical
shows that light iron and heavy carbonate scale can be removed
with a mixture of acids that are used in Liquid Acid Descaler.
Any iron bacteria associated with scales treated with Liquid
Acid Descaler are naturally destroyed by the acid.
COTEY'S Liquid Acid Descaler
also acts as an excellent chelating agent for a number of metals.
This simply means that the acid exhibits a complexing ability
for iron in its anionic form, thus increasing the iron solubility.
Situations often arise when
standard acid treatment periods, and increased concentrations
are required, particularly when waste pumpage continues to
show incrustation debris being removed from the well.
It should be emphasized that
the removal of such scales and the resultant debris from the
well will become increasingly effective as the pH of the water
is lowered, thus copious quantities of acid are often required
and frequent monitoring of discharge is suggested.
Bacteria and Related
Incrustations
The accumulation of nuisance
organisms such as fungi, algae, molds and various bacteria
is a real problem in some areas. Generally speaking, this problem
is best solved by preventive treatments rather than waiting
until the well is plugged. Usually these organisms can be controlled
if every well is sterilized with some accepted method when
the well is first completed and then treated periodically.
And of prime importance is to construct the well to eliminate
any surface contamination. If growths of nuisance organisms
are present they can be cleaned up with suitable chemicals
and then kept under control with periodic treatments.
All water wells, even if used
for cropland irrigation, stock or industrial purposes, should
be periodically sterilized. The common test for water pollution
is for the presence of coliform bacteria which originates in
the intestinal tracts of warm blooded animals. Certainly, the
presence of any coliform content in well water shows that other
pathogens may also be present which could transmit dysentery,
infectious hepatitis, burcellosis or salmonellosis to humans,
or scours to swine and livestock. In fact, although caution
is seldom exercised in supplying stock water, polluted water
will produce a higher than average mortality rate in most animals,
being particularly noticeable in slow weight gains and abortions
in swine and cattle.
The standard method of treating
water supplies for bacterial pollution is by chlorination,
unlike chlorine gas, which can be easily and safely added to
a well, the complete chemical reaction occurring within the
well. Although, admittedly, chlorine gas would produce a quicker
result, its use requires special equipment for injection. Chlorine
gas is also extremely poisonous, thus few landowners care to
have wells treated with such a dangerous chemical, particularly
when the wells are near large livestock herds or neighbor's
houses: a ruptured hose could result in dead stock and immediate
human evacuation!
For many years it has been customary
for drillers and household occupants to "disinfect" their
water wells with liquid bleach bought at the local supermarket.
Such "supermarket bleach" usually contains a 5% solution
of calcium hypochlorite and 95% water. While this method is
scientifically correct, results are generally 90% worthless
due to the low level of chlorine concentration in the bleach
and the small amount of bleach commonly used. As a typical
example let's take a 400 foot, 12 inch well with 300 feet of
water. This well contains approximately 2000 gallons of water
(actually 1765), thus, to reach a chlorine concentration of
+ 500 ppm will require about 20 gallons of bleach. Unfortunately,
treatment of this well, by the "supermarket method",
would probably consist of dumping one jug of laundry bleach
down the hole rather than the 20 jugs actually needed to do
the minimum job! When chlorine is added to a well it hydrolyzes,
producing hydrogen (H+), chlorine (Cl-) and hypochlorous acid
(HOCl). Although weak, the hypochlorous acid smothers the pathogens
and dissociates by giving off hydrogen. Unfortunately, many
wells treated with chlorine fail to experience an effective "kill" due
to changes which occur during treatment. Let's examine these
difficulties to insure that your treatments with chlorine is
always effective.
The amount of chlorine used
in a well treatment is divisible into the demand, the dosage,
and the residual. The demand chlorine is the amount necessary
to effect the "kill", the dosage chlorine is the
amount placed in the well, and the residual is the excess chlorine
remaining after the "kill". The majority of chlorination
procedures experience trouble when only the demand chlorine
is met. For example, if well water is excessively alkaline
the hypochlorous acid is dissociated and the efficiency of
the chlorine reduced. Secondly, as the water temperature decreases,
the effectiveness of the chlorine also decreases (about 50%
per 10 degrees F decrease). Thirdly, chlorine efficiency is
reduced by well waters having a high nitrogen (N) content which
allows formation of inorganic or organic chlorimines. Any organic
debris, incidentally, will also preferentially utilize the
chlorine, and the presence of incrustations will shield pathogens
from the chlorine. Finally, any hydrogen sulfide (H2s) in the
system will combine with available chlorine to form hydrochloric
acid which, as we've seen, would be detrimental to a silty
well.
Fortunately, the solutions to
all of these possible problems are provided by COTEY'S chemical
products. Basically, any well, regardless of production history,
should be cleaned prior to chlorination. Secondly, although
some chlorine treatment procedures recommend the use of + 50
ppm chloride concentrations (Texas Highway Department), others
100 to 200 ppm concentrations, and still others at 1000 ppm,
COTEY CHEMICAL recommends concentrations of between 400 and
500 ppm for the usual applications, but less than 1000 ppm
to hold corrosive effects to a minimum. The reasons for this
concentration (500 ppm) are, in addition to those previously
stated, to provide that excess of residual chlorine which,
as a strong oxidizer, can react with many of the polluting
chemicals and incrustations commonly found in wells. As an
example, the detrimental effects of nitrates in ground water
have been a subject of intense study, primarily because the
nitrates (NO3) convert to nitrites (NO2) in the presence of
bacteria or zinc. It is the nitrites which cause cyanosis ("blue
babies") in infants. This problem can be eliminated by
using chlorine. Other cations such as sulphur (which will form
hydrogen sulfide gas), iron and magnesium can also be effectively
removed from well water by the extra strong chorine concentration
recommended by COTEY.
For well systems where iron
bacteria have been allowed to flourish, resulting in massive
incrustation, (pictured above), COTEY CHEMICAL recommends what
is usually termed a "shock chlorination" treatment.
Shock chlorination is produced by using a 1000 ppm chlorine
concentration (roughly double the amount stipulated above)
after a preliminary acid/chelation treatment with Liquid Acid
Descaler . Such a treatment usually takes three to four days
and requires displacement water and exact timing. This sequence
is repeated until the waste returns clean or down-time is exhausted.
However, a word of caution, chlorination of water with a high
ferrous iron content will cause precipitation of the gelatinous
hydrated ferric compounds due to the oxidizing effect of the
chlorine unless the pH is kept below 3 to keep the ferric iron
in solution. It should be remembered that when iron bacteria
are present they are converting the ferrous iron to the ferric
state within the well, thus chlorine treatment should be preceded
by acidization to kill such bacteria before injection of the
chlorine.
Many water wells commonly
contain bacterial "slimes" in the form of gelatinous
incrustations which plug gravel packs, well screen and/or casing
perforations. Such "slimes" are produced by iron
and sulfate reducing bacteria, the dissolved oxygen in the
water favoring presence of iron bacteria (Crenothrix). Thus,
the problem in such wells is not simply to remove the "slime",
but to eliminate the bacteria causing the incrustations.
Several of COTEY'S products
can be used to remove the incrustations. For example, if the
incrustations are mixed with calcium carbonate, use Dry Acid® Special,
if the incrustations are an iron/manganese base, use Liquid
Acid Descaler , and if the incrustations are mainly silt and
clay, use Dry Acid® or Mud-Nox®. Following removal
of the incrustations the well is now ready for sterilization.
There are many chemicals available
for sterilization of water wells, but the particular chemical
used must be carefully selected. The most commonly used chemicals
are chlorine, quaternary compounds, copper sulfate and formaldehyde,
but unfortunately, chlorine and formaldehyde, though very effective,
have only a short-term effect. Copper sulfate, a popular chemical
treatment for removal of weeds, algae and protozoa, should
not be used on wells which supply domestic water because of
the toxicity of copper to living organisms: also copper sulfate
is corrosive to aluminum. Use in irrigation wells should also
be curtailed because of injurious effects of copper to most
crops. COTEY CHEMICAL has therefore developed Welgicide® Cleaner
, which is specifically formulated for odor, taste, bacterial
and organic "slime" problems.
Welgicide® Cleaner is very
effective when used during the months when the wells are not
being used in that its bactericidal efficiency remains potent
for several weeks. When incrustations contain appreciable amounts
of oil (probably from oil-lubricated pumps), organic "slimes",
tree roots and vegetative debris from up-hole, and even carcasses
of small animals, COTEY'S Welgicide® Cleaner should be
used. Welgicide® Cleaner is a mixture of detergency, sequestering,
defflocculation, and buffering properties in addition to the
strong alkaline properties of all the ingredients. As such,
Welgicide® Cleaner is one of the most versatile and effective
chemical treatments offered by COTEY.
Maintenance Treatment
Deterioration of a water well's
yield is somewhat analogous to the development of periodontal
(dental) disease. Once the disease destroys a certain amount
of bone structure the teeth become relatively useless, and
once incrustations or silting reach a certain point in a water
well, well yields are "useless". Fortunately, water
wells (like dental structure) can be kept in optimum operating
condition by preventative treatments; COTEY CHEMICAL recommends
such treatments for a well at least once a year. Needless to
say, it is far easier to prevent incrustations and corrosion
than it is to remove such deposits.
Iron bacteria have characteristically
been difficult to remove from water wells, often reappearing
quickly after even the shock chlorination treatments. Chlorination
treatments at regular intervals should therefore be implemented
to maintain well yield and insure against the buildup of massive
incrustations which could completely destroy yield or necessitate
several weeks down-time for necessary treatment.
Installation of a drip chlorinator
is, in fact, one of the best investments for many water wells.
Drip chlorination to either the pump, pressure tanks (if present),
or lines, in various concentrations depending on the local
well problem, can prevent the infestation of iron bacteria
by killing the bacteria and even precipitating the iron from
the water. Drip chlorination will also prevent the development
of iron and manganese scale, and eliminate any coliform bacteria.
Over an extended period the chlorine can be expected to eliminate
any iron scale remaining on the well's screen and pump. While
doing all of the above, drip chlorination also removes any
sulphur, nitrate, manganese and iron in the water.
The continual addition to water
wells of polyphosphates, as chlorine, will prevent iron scale
formation in the well system or in irrigation channels by keeping
the iron in soluble form and causing precipitation of the iron
respectively. In-line filters should be used if the water is
piped to households.
Concluding Remarks
The loss of flow in many wells
is due simply to a lowering of the water table. In this case
there is nothing that can be done except drill more wells or
use less water.
The problem is not how or why
the water is plugged off but how best to remove plugging so
that maximum flow can be obtained. Fortunately, much of the
plugging will be removed by bailing, swabbing, surging, backwashing
or pumping. Dry ice is sometimes used to agitate the water.
Compressed air is also used to build up pressure and to air-lift
the well in an effort to remove all plugging. As we have pointed
out before, you will note that in all these methods the pressure
being used is applied in the same direction as that which put
the plugging in place. There is nothing that can be done to
change the water pressure in the formation. Mechanical agitation
in the bore hole will certainly help to loosen the mud but
it is still the water from the formation that must wash it
out. Since everything in the hole is completely hydrated and
water wet, the water can not help in any way other that its
mechanical washing action.
Chemicals are available that
are effective in removing practically any type of accumulation
from water wells. Instead of spending a lot of time trying
to completely remove all plugging by mechanical methods, a
properly designed chemical treatment will make it possible
to do the job better and in less time. Many times one section
may be overdeveloped in order to adequately develop another
section. By chemically treating along with the usual mechanical
methods all sections can be developed uniformly. Cotey Chemical's
products were developed with the thought in mind that they
would be used by well drilling contractors, pump companies
and well service companies. Consequently, they are packaged
in small, easy to handle containers, and usually no additional
equipment is needed. Many wells equipped with deep well turbine
pumps are treated with the pump in the hole. The chemical is
simply poured in the well between the casing and pump column
and the pump is used to agitate and dissolve the chemical in
the water standing in the hole. The pump is used to agitate
periodically for about 24 hours and then the well is pumped
and developed in the usual manner.
In developing new wells or redeveloping
old wells with a rig over the hole, the chemicals are added
and a bailer, surge block or other tool is used for agitation.
The well is then bailed or the pump set to remove the spent
acid solution. The big advantage with chemicals is the fact
that they can penetrate through the screen or casing perforations
and back into the formation where there is little if any agitation
from mechanical methods.
As pointed out earlier, deep
penetration is not needed, so usually no additional water is
added to the well unless the static water level is considerably
above the perforations. In gravel packed wells enough water
is usually added to displace the chemical solution back through
the gravel wall to the formation where it can act to disintegrate
and dissolve the mud and clay.
In some wells the chemical is
dissolved in water and the solution added through the drill
pipe or tubing. Our experience has been that it is easier and
cheaper to use an excess of chemical and dissolve it in the
water standing in the hole. In this way none of the chemical
is lost in the open porous sections as happens when a solution
is added to a well at static.
Most of the chemicals are comparatively
non-toxic and are used to treat wells producing potable water.
The first water produced after a treatment contains spent chemicals
and should be pumped to waste. Most wells will clean up in
only a few hours depending on the size and equipment being
used. |